Flying nonstop across the Eurasian landmass had great appeal at the time although airfares at that time were still awfully steep.
As was the excessive appearance of some airline hostesses. You had to make sure to fly Foxy Lady
not her bushy tailed vulpine sister.
So going overland in my seven-league boots, supplemented by a few student concession flights, would allow me to take in many exotic lands and peoples at more or less the same cost. My earlier safari had taught me how to start on the logistics and hazards of travelling in Asia at a basic level. The bare necessities. My plan would be to sample some of India’s spice, courtesy of her railway system leading me to hop it to the ‘schoolhouse in the clouds’ in Nepal and the archaeological treasure of Mohenjo-daro in Pakistan after which I would pick up the Hippy Trail proper.
A Train of Impressions
Calcutta provided the inevitable culture shock and assault on the senses that no amount of reading could prepare one for. The sheer mass of humanity. My first morning there, I was awakened by it’s smell. Hardly a reassuring place, I could not but be wrenched at the sights and sounds of the unparalleled human poverty and degradation. Destitute men, women and urchins living their private lives in the street, in unimaginable poverty and often abject squalor, some disfigured by accident, amputation or disease, imploring eyes and outstretched hands asking for “Baksheesh”. Crumbling tenements, hygiene horror, sleeping masses in every nook and cranny, wrapped in cloth like corpses, touts and panhandlers wherever I trod, overflowing garbage clumps, rats in a park better fed than many people.
At the same time people seem happy in this colourful madness, smiling at you and acting kindly to each other. Above the din of the incessant traffic , horns blaring,cows mooing,poor people pedalled languidly on upright bicycles, marching with their briefcases through the dust, people washed clothes in open drains and showered from hoses. Everywhere you looked there was industry lined on either side of the street,everybody on the move. Commerce hummed in tiny spaces with people buying or selling something. Sidewalk vendors hawking their wares, stallholding chefs serving up their own tasty specialities, cobblers mending shoes, pavement barbers, customers haggling vociferously. The smell of spices, dust and thronging humanity hanging over everything. Sensory overload. Plunging into the bum to bumper pandemonium of hand pulled rickshaws, stray animals,pedestrians buses and honking cars and pedestrians,I realised all you need to drive in India is a horn,a good set of brakes and nerves of steel.It was pure chaos but—it worked! People got around.
I toured the city threading through and breaking free of the snarls of traffic, looking to change some money in a place where the dollar remained more valuable than oxygen, of which there was precious little.
At every turn I came across the beauty hiding behind it’s poxy camouflage.India is absolute disorder but soon you begin to think of it as vibrancy, life and a riot of colour.
Later I ventured into the meat hall at Hogg Market. Butchers in blood-stained vests hacking away at bone and gristle, hunks of raw mutton hanging from the ceilings, entrails set out for inspection on marble slabs, bluebottle flies buzzing around them, I was put off meat for some time. Fortunately superb vegetarian food was widely available in this crazy city which more than made up for it. The virtue of vegetarianism was made apparent to me as much by this offal offering as any conscious ethical decision like Gandhi’s.
I teamed up with Carol Henderson, a Sydney public school teacher, heading the same way. It didn’t take long to find the hidden jewels. An aging Anglo-Indian lady came up to us in the street and invited us to have Christmas dinner with her and her family. Carol and I were treated as honourable guests and met the lady’s granddaughter whose beauty to me surpassed that of the Taj Mahal.
I asked our host, ‘Why are there so many beggars in Calcutta?’
She said, ‘Calcutta isn’t known as ‘The Dying City’ for nothing. That’s because much of it’s industry was killed off. For at least two centuries Bengal used to be the centre of a thriving textile industry. The forebears of these beggars would have been involved in it either in production or trade. Our handloom weavers produced some of the world’s most desirable traditionally woven fabrics. She showed me some of her heirloom dresses, laying them out on the dining table. ‘These fine long muslins have been in my family for generations.’
‘Covering a multitude of shins,’I said.
Holding a simple white dress against her granddaughters figure she said, ‘This one was made locally. As you can see the fabric is perfect for clothing in hot countries. Feel how fine it is. It’s so delicate it can fit through a finger ring. is so delicate that it can fit through a finger ring is so delicate that it can fit through a finger ring’
‘The British must have snapped them up to send home.’
‘That’s not just what they snapped. These objects of desire and symbols of luxury were so cheap that Britain’s own cloth manufacturers conspired to cut off the fingers of Bengali weavers and break their looms. To stop their import duties were imposed. They flooded our market with their own cheap fabric – cheaper even than poorly paid Bengali artisans could provide. Now this embroidered gown,’she said indicating another, ‘came from cotton fabrics produced on the looms of the west of Scotland.’
‘India could still grow cotton.’
‘India still grew cotton, but Bengal no longer spun or wove much of it.’
‘That must have led to a lot of unemployment.’
‘Weavers became beggars and so it passed on to their descendants through the ensuing years. People lost the skill of their fingers, and only the roughest-made country cloth still found a market among the poorest.’
What do you look for now in your everyday clothing?’
I try to wear clothes handcrafted from traditional Indian cloth made on the handloom.That’s my small part of boycotting imports.This is what loin clothed Gandhi at his spinning wheel encouraged us to do.For him weaving every morning was his way of saying ‘I believe in practising what I preach’.
Meantime it was time for me to get my own chakras spinning.My official exercise was to have my student card accepted so that I would be able to travel the Indian railway system 3rd class at the concession rate. This involved a whole day going to offices where clerks knee deep in memoranda clattered away on type writers. plugged along under tardy turning ceiling fans, These merely redistributed the hot, moist air around every corner of the room. Bundles of paperwork, trussed in red tape at desks were piled high. Every detail of every piece of paper was being hand-written with fountain pens and the ink carefully blotted. An element of distinction and authority was added with wax seal.
To describe the transport this entitled me to as ‘no frills’ is an understatement. Padding and legroom on the ‘hardseaters’ went by the board.They were as comfortable as a bed of nails, There was no room to swing a rat. However it was definitely economical and it sure beat having to thumb rides with oxen carts and overcrowded cars on unruly Indian roads. So it was I headed to the Nepal. After the cascade of other bone-weary eyed passengers tumbled out of the train at the border, I looked for a bus to nearby Birganj from where I could fly to Lukla via Kathmandu.
Noting the footprints of other trekkers as I climbed through the Sulo-Khumbu region, famous for its sheer beauty and the friendliness of its Sherpa people brought to my mind the man these people see as their godfather. Edmund Hillary whose grandeur matched those of the surrounding masses left his footprint in a major way. He had told me he was still climbing, a practice he had picked up in his native New Zealand after he had left the Air Force. As is well known he was the first to reach the summit of Mt Everest with Sherpa Tenzing Norgay. He told me about the hospital he was building up here for the Sherpa people.
The brilliantly eloquent answer given to people who ask why climbers scale mountains is “because it is there”. It’s the same answer I normally give for going round them. But on this occasion I had a special reason to go up . My objective was to visit both the hospital and the school Hillary had set up.
Reaching the lovely villages of Khumjung and neighbouring Khunde, home to the Sherpas who had accompanied him on his ascent, involved first hopping from Kathmandu to the-gulp!- razor scrape Lukla runway which faces a cliff.
I had chosen to sit in the tail end of the plane . I’d never heard of one backing into a mountain.
‘Do planes flying here crash often?’ I asked as we approached the runway.
‘No, only once.’
The flaps of our plane were set to full down and it slowed to a little over stall speed..
‘Wow, this is some short runway,’I said wiping my brow, ready to put my head between my knees as the plane screeched to a stop, tyres smoking.
‘Yes,’agreed a fellow passenger, but look how wide it is.’
After touchdown I put on my seven league boots for the journey ahead.A trek of several days moving up and down these lower reaches of the ranges. This necessitated some strenuous and vigorous hiking and climbing on my part. Valderi,Valdera!
In this invigorating air, my tank topped up with boiled eggs and chocolate, I replenished the at least 6, 000 calories I burned each day.
The trail took me through wooded pine scented hillsides populated by brilliant red rhododendron, magnolia, birches, and giant firs, decorated with lichens and mosses, boulders standing in between , dappled in the filtered sunlight. The narrow sometimes crumbling paths took me past terraced fields hugging the hillsides, laden with potatoes, barley and roses, orchards of apple trees and lush meadows with grazing yaks, bells aringing, ting-a-ling-a-ling, ting-a-ling-a-ling. It took me through a rich tapestry of numerous small villages, all sturdy stonework with colourful roofs, monasteries, religious icons. The tap tap of masons chipping rocks into neat cubes for walls and foundations was a constant sound. As was the water. Wherever my group were, we could hear it in the distance, roaring and churning . Crossing a variety of remarkable suspension bridges floating at dizzying heights over rushing milky green torrents was another high point of the trek. I hung onto my hat crossing as the wind whistled along the valleys.
The nearest roads being about fifty miles south of Lukla, muscle power had to be the dominant form of haulage. Trains of beasts of burden- donkeys and various breeds of yaks plodding along, heavily laden, ferrying goods around greeted us at every turn.. You could hear them coming by the bells around their necks.Large holes in the vegetation were reminders of where even sure-footed beasts of burden slipped off the muddy trails and crashed down the side of the mountain.
Then there were the fast breathing porters, men and women, both very young and very old, carrying more oxygen than people from the plains, carrying straw cone baskets with back-crushing weights of wood, food, fodder, fuel, pelts, building materials and so on . Everything but the kitchen sink. With backs bent at the hip they set a steady pace, whatever load they had attached around their shoulders, supported with a headband around their forehead.
At day’s end the group I was with sheltered in windowless lodges with holes in the roofs, from which billowed fluffy columns of smoke. Typically we all sat thigh to thigh on goat skins on the dirt floors full of sacks and baskets holding potatoes, turnips, cornmeal, and stacks of drying yak dung, to be used as cooking fuel. Our black haired, red-cheeked, smiling hosts offered bread, rice and lentil soup filled with whatever random vegetables happen to be lying around at the time, and endless cups of pungent tea laced with yak butter milk, salt and who knows what else.
The old ways persisted in most aspects of my hosts’ daily life. Their washing machine was the rushing river. Their dryer was the sun. The kids used round pebbles as marbles and played catch with potatoes. With rocks and branches, the farmers constructed diversion channels beside the mountain streams to drive the waterwheels that ground their grain into flour.
Putting aside the donkey droppings I had to duck and the bloodsucking, burrowing leeches I had to brush off, the yak track led me through a geography of superlatives. It brought me to me a vertiginous panorama of ice and snow clad peaks, including the “Mother of the Universe”, wispy flutes of snow flaking from them. Poking up above the steep sides of the gorges, they soared miles into the heavens, like jagged gleaming teeth threatening to tear a hole in the pure blue sky. Their purity, their silence, their huge imperviousness returned me, craning my neck, to a childlike sense of hand-to-mouth awe. To complete this mystical scene, the air sparkling with ice crystals, high above a griffon glided majestically on the thermals, its vulturous wings resembling giant black fangs.
On the last leg of the journey up and up I went, step after step, each one asking tough questions of my thigh and calf muscles. Pausing every now and then, hands on knees, I bent over and strained for breath. My sugar level threatened to fall, my groin was aching, my knees were begging for mercy and as we moved higher and higher I had to heave my quivering, leaden left leg up with my hands just to keep it moving. At last the ground suddenly levelled off and the tops of buildings rose into view. We’d reached Khumjung and I could still just about stand upright. Just about.
On the way to the Everest base camp, Khumjung, sitting in a high valley, is a point of departure for scaling the heights of Everest and the roof of the world. Reaching the village was just a warm up for some of the serious mountaineers who would acclimatize before setting out for the camp. Reaching there was to be higher than on a lot of mountains but like they say, the Himalayas begin where other mountains end.
Having arrived at my destination, that evening I was rewarded with a sunset on the giants to the north. The earth’s shadow crept up the mountainsides, night pressing on rapidly, the distant summits glisten warmly in the final glow of sunlight. Everest, Lhotse and Ama Dablam all turned to gold, then red then pink while streaming snow from their summits. At last the lights went out and left a momentary radiance in the atmosphere, a purple hue. In that short time between light and darkness the world was still and silent and peaceful. In the south the valley we’d come up filled in with evening cloud, swirling around and up and down the mountain slopes like a slow motion tidal wave. Come morning I was treated to yet another splendidly spectacular display with blazes of orange as the sun rose, casting the white Himalayan peaks in a fiery glow.
The school at Khumjung, , the jewel in Sir Ed’s crown, was a simple affair, but it was life changing for the Sherpa people ‘The school satisfies a deepfelt need’, the schoolmaster of the Khumjung primary school told me. One elder put it to Hillary this way: ‘Our children have eyes, but they are blind. Therefore, we would want you to open their eyes by building a school in our village of Khumjung, Sahib,” he said. “Of all the things you have, learning is the one we most desire for our children.” “Of all the things you have, learning is the one we most desire for our children.” They want to read and write so much. So much so they spend ages each day walking up and down hillsides from surrounding villages on rock strewn mountain trails . In the monsoon, they hoof it in the rain. In winter, they hoof it in the snow.’
‘They certainly keep their eye on the ball,’I said, observing their field and batsmanship. .. A game of cricket was in progress when I turned up.
“Those boys out there all want to be the next Don Bradman,” he said as we watched them tallying runs on the school’s hard-mud playing field. ‘Sir Ed introduced them to his legend and his sport. Although this landlocked strip of land was never a British colony like India, cricket still managed to make its way up the mountains.’
’ I looked in on one of the two the aluminium clad classrooms built mostly with Hillary’s own hands himself. Nothing more than a few benches with a black board at the front, the kids inside were reading quietly and intently before rattling off questions of their teacher. As parents gave priority to their sons, there weren’t many girls. Their eyes lit up when I was introduced and they surrounded me asking questions about Australia. Apart from their common love for cricket the enthusiasm brimming in the children for the reading and writing contrasted so greatly with that ennui you can often encounter in many of our schools. You don’t need fancy buildings to educate people.
‘The school and others in the group set up by Bada Sahib, the Sherpa term of respect for Hillary, has enabled the people to develop their skills and preserve their culture’, he said.
‘I sent Sir Ed my good wishes with regard to this success for which he thanked me .’
His whole contribution has a lot to do with wishes. He once asked a Sherpa elder if he could do anything to help the man’s village. The man replied affirmatively and from that moment Sir Ed became the man who granted wishes.’
Before entering the small stone hospital at Khunde, Khumjung’s ‘sister city’, I stopped to observe the industry and craftsmanship of a trio of men carrying out stonework along it’s wall. I then admired the educational drawings about health, child care and sanitation posted outside the clinic. Most of the patients are illiterate so simple drawings showing such things as how to clean their teeth got the message across. An increase in dental decay had followed contact with the outside world and discovery of the sweet tooth..
‘The hospital carries out both curative and preventative measures’, the volunteer doctor told me. These have had a lasting impact on the hard lives of the Sherpa people. The hospital spearheaded the drive to eliminate the threat of smallpox here. It introduced iodine to help eradicate goitre, which was widespread until recently.’
‘Are these modern medical treatments accepted by the populace?’
‘Yes, by and large. but that has not stopped people from a continued reliance on herbal medicine, on faith healing, and on shamans . When it comes to medicine, they are openminded. They come in here and get vaccinated against measles or polio, and then they go to the monastery and get an amulet from the lama to ward off the same disease.”
‘Hedging their bets.’
They are deeply invested in both traditional and western ways’, he said, pointing to one of the nurses.’This young lady is training to become a nursing sister. She takes her turn with others to work here without financial payment. It’s the same with those men you see outside repairing the wall. Sir Ed stresses the importance of self help.’
As with the school, the involvement of the locals in the running and upkeep of the hilltop hospital was clear.
The doctor drew attention to what Sir Ed once said: “ ‘I’ve never done anything that they’ve never asked for. It always comes from them’
I asked him ‘What is the most important thing remaining to be done here?’
‘You might think I would say that health care is the most important thing to be done. But no, education is number one. It opens up a world of possibility and it’s essential for us to communicate information and ideas.’
Having doubled back downhill, I was reminded of his work when taking off from the Lukla runway built on a daunting slope, at an angle of 12 degrees uphill because of the lack of flat ground. The airstrip was paid for by the Hillary Trust to give the Sherpas better access to the outside world.
Like Pearl Buck, Sir Ed helped to foster better understanding between people from East and West. He summed up his work thus: “The most worthwhile things I have done are the serious projects for the mountain people of the Himalaya.’
Like Pearl Buck he benefited people other than his own and became one of them.
Down from the Mountains.
In Australia the era of steam engines had ground to an end as I was growing up, but not so in India. The sounds of the gigantic locomotives, objects of high romance, chuffing, chugging, whistling, sending up billowing plumes of steam, churning steel, wood, and dust relentlessly, generating wind , soot and smoke, wheels clickety- clacking over the points, the jog and sway of the clanking carriage, and the heavy noise from the puffing billies crossing iron bridges have kept playing in my head ever since. The smell and prickle of coal dust on my skin have tarried in my pores long after. As have remained in my mind’s eye fleeting scenes from outside the doors and open windows of my carriage: cows lingering on neighbouring tracks, friends chatting in huddles by them , pyramid-like salt mounds drying in the sunshine, ladies banging washing, men squatting in circles playing cards, the backs of people’s houses so close up you could see what they’re eating for breakfast.
The railway is an institution in India and a world of its own. It began and ended at the Indian railway station. A locomotive pick and mix of sizes, speeds, shapes and colours – that was just the passengers. Swarming with life, an army of bawling, crowing tea and food wallahs was always on hand offering them their products. The tea makers boiled and stirred, teeming and ladling, adding their particular blend of ginger, garam masala or saffron to give their tea its own aromatic identity. They served it in disposable clay vessels which patrons threw down on the ground after they finished. Walking along the platform involved wading through their smashed fragments which littered it.
The station was an ideal place to meet people. Well goodness gracious me, someone with a veddy Peter Sellers accent would invariably waltz up, eager to engage in conversation to improve their English and, shaking their head from side to side, satisfy their boundless curiosity about the wider world.
The travellers advised me how to best make my journey. They knew so much about trains, not because they were trainspotters or enthusiasts, but because trains were the mainstay of Indian travel. Roads were a dangerous adventure, planes the reserve of the privileged. People knew the best trains and the worst, the quickest and the slowest, the routes, the numbers. ‘You need to ask for the Gorakhpur slip coach on the 9 Up, that way you don’t have to change at Jhansi.’ ‘Never take the Upper India Express. Oof! It takes for ever.’ ‘Try the tea stall at Gwalior. Kapoor’s. The tea is really bang up.’
They knew about outer signals, loop lines, up trains and down trains, They knew the difference between different categories of train: mail, express, fast passenger and passenger. They pored through their copies of the railway travellers guide, ploughing through the tiny grey print of its timetables to determine how the family and its several trunks would reach their destination, say. The guide listed every train in India from everywhere to everywhere else, noting their arrival and departure timings at every station, including minor wayside halts. They were, in this aspect of their knowledge and behaviour, like Victorians.
The station was heaving.Everyone seemed to be on the rattletraps. Four hours after mine was due I was riding again, introduced to an endless hustle and bustle of people from a vast array of ethnic religious and economic backgrounds. The crowding and the chaos left me with the impression that most everyone in the country was trying to cram into the same train as me. Dodging and shouldering one another to board, lugging boxes and bed rolls, they piled into the compartments, and scooched down in the corridors. Tightly packed bodies twisted and bent to be shoehorned into every crevice of the train car.
I learned the main rule of life in India: ‘There’s always room’. I impressed my fellow travellers on one occasion by picking up a guy trying to nest in the luggage rack and depositing him there. Riding the rails, the relaxed anonymity proved to be a perfect setting for travellers to reveal to me perspectives on their world.
After arriving back in northern India from Nepal I got on a train heading for Delhi. I struck up some lively conversation with others in my compartment. One I remember was an American hippy. ‘I’m studying ancient Hindu texts’, he said. ‘This is it’s classical guide to a virtuous and gracious living,’he declared, pulling out his copy of the ‘Kama Sutra’ from his rucksack. With all the other passengers in the compartment sharing the insight of this illustrated version, I’m sure it ended up putting them in an awkward position.
I ended up putting another fellow passenger, a misty-eyed Raj romantic in an equally awkward position. I engaged in converstion with this brolly bearing anglophile, dressed most impractically for this hot, humid environment in a worsted woollen three piece suit and pointy beige shoes. He never loosened the buttons of his coat even when mercury crossed the thermometer’s 110F mark.
As well there was the passenger with a strong sense of Gandhian attachment. Unsurprisingly he was wearing a white Nehru jacket with it’s short stand-up collar.
Tea and travel being synonymous in India, when the train halted outside one of the stations on the way us passengers, took refreshment from the railway tea stall while the anglophile kept his gladstone bag well clear of the open window,. On the platform the chai maker was busily brewing and serving. After we placed our orders through the open window to his son, the boy manoeuvred his way to the stall and back to us through the crowd with his little tray of clay cups.
As we sipped our tea we were treated to the most basic percussive offering. Two beats on the station bell, in this case a length of old rail struck with a hammer, told us a down train on the down line was going the other way.
‘This drink is a staple of Indian life,’said the anglophile, ‘Just as it is for you British. It’s our national drink, to all intents and purposes.’
‘Well I’m not British , I’m Australian .’I said, aware that I was legally a British subject whatever that meant in practice.
‘Actually no, but I agree with you on the importance we all place on tea..’
‘And to think it didn’t come from India. It was the British who brought it here. It was the British East India Company who established the tea trade in India. British tea merchants eventually spread it’s consumption here. One of the ways they would do this was that they would go to railway stations like this one and serve free tea and milk.’
‘You make them sound all so generous,’said the republican, ‘They just pushed it to expand their market. To end their dependence on Chinese tea, the Company set up plantations here. They felled vast forests, stripped the tribals who lived there of their rights, and then paid Indian labourers poorly to cultivate the cleared areas. Once the tea was ready, it was shipped off to Britain or sold internationally. The little bit left in India was too expensive, until the Great Depression. Weak global demand and the potential of the big Indian domestic market finally let Indians enjoy the delights of the drink they produced.’
‘Throw in our sugar and they had us hooked. We don’t have them to thank for that. We Indians discovered how to crystallize sugar way back around the time Jesus was preaching in Judea. Way before the British brought slaves to the West Indies to produce it.’
‘Whether West Indian sugarcane producers, Indian tea pickers or Australian sheep farmers, we’re all freemen these days. As members of the British Commonwealth we share a common bond. We share the legacy of this great civilizing culture. As Edmund Burke put it, these were, and I maintain still are, ties ‘which, though light as air, are as strong as links of iron.’
‘As light and strong as the chains that shackled those sugarcane cultivators you mention.’
‘Had it not been for the British there would never have been the entity called India.’
‘Fiddlesticks! As far back as emperor Ashoka, about 300 BC, large parts of the subcontinent enjoyed cultural and administrative unity.’
‘I don’t know what happened back then but the sub-continent became divided later. The British provided Indians the tools and institutions needed to hold the union together and run it.’
‘There were limits to how long they could hold it together. In their entire two centuries rule, they made up no more than a tiny percentage of the population. And, yet, for most of that period, no Indian was allowed to join the Indian Civil Service, in part because the British could not bear to take orders from a brown man. Britain’s policy was not to unite but to divide and rule.’
British rule may not have been better than the despots of earlier empires but it wasn’t worse.’
‘Few kings or dictators ever rule to benefit their people. We’re constantly reminded of the millions who’ve perished during the purges and famines of Stalin and Mao. Please consider also India’s famines during the Raj: Between 1770 and 1947, the oppressed suffered at least eleven major ones and many minor ones, resulting in thirty five million deaths. The empire’s record of forced migration is no better. To be an indentured Indian labourer was to enter a life-and-death lottery in which your chances of survival were significantly worse than those of a shackled African slave. None of this is anything to be proud of. Can you justify any of that ?’
‘I can’t. No one can. But no one can deny the positive heritage. Not everyone threw their caps in the air in 1947. My family have been associated with the British for generations and I want this to continue. I attended a British public school in Delhi which gave me an entrée to world culture. I spent my best days in that wonderful country Britain. I became such good friends with so many that this independence thing hardly comes to my mind. The British helped shape the attitudes and tastes of the tens of millions of English-speaking Indians.We learned from the best. Hows that for openers?
‘Sure they brought cricket to both our shores. But didn’t they take our polo back to their little island reserving it for their own brahmins . Granted man does not live by chapati alone … but he doesn’t live long without it.’
“I can only speak for myself. I’m passionate about playing and following the gentlemanly sport . So much of what we take for granted in our daily life – the books we read, the way we eat, sometimes the way we dress, our habits and cultural allusions – have come from their time here, from British institutions and the English language,” he said.
‘One thing is undeniable They brought trains to India and left an expansive railway system far in advance of any other Asian nation.’
‘Apart from gifting Indians a fantastic railway system, an advanced legal system, parliamentary democracy, free trade, advanced medicine, technical education, what more can Indians accuse the British of denying them?’he asked rhetorically.
‘A progressive taxation system-one without a gun raised to their head. Now let’s be serious. They denied us entry to the British market for their manufactured goods. They denied us the ability to share in the great prosperity being made from our efforts. Lets look at the railways since that’s where we are right now. Sure they were first conceived of by the East India Company, but like everything else in that firm’s calculations, the network was for its own benefit. The Company only did what was best for the Company. The network was set up for the commerce, government and military control of the country. It was established to more effectively move goods and extracted raw minerals to ports for the British to ship home to use in their factories. And of course to move troops more effectively to wherever they were needed to quell rebellions against their colonial rip off.’
‘You don’t see it as a gift to the people of India. Think of the industry it created. Don’t you see it as a blessing?’
‘Hardly. It was unintended. In their very conception and construction, the Indian railways were a colonial scam. Any benefits that accrued came only by accident. British shareholders made absurd amounts of money by investing in the railways, where the government guaranteed returns double those of government stocks, paid entirely from Indian, and not British, taxes.
‘So If the railway company couldn’t achieve that return on its own, then the government made up the shortfall from its revenues.’
‘It was a perfect sellers market. And a a splendid racket for Britons, at the expense of the Indian taxpayer. The railways were financed by an elaborate and shonky scam that enriched British investors by inflating the cost of Indian rail track to twice that of Australia and Canada.’
‘Do I understand you correctly?A mile of Indian railway cost double the same distance in the equally difficult terrain of Canada and Australia.
Correct. It was a licence to print money. Private enterprise at public risk. Socialism for the investors.’
‘Who presumably weren’t Indian.’
‘No surprises there. Only one percent of railway shares originated in India. Most of the rest came from small shareholders with addresses in southern England: from bankers, barristers, spinsters, retired army officers and people known simply as ‘gentlemen’. Their individual holdings were not large but the total invested meant that India’s railways represented one of the 19th century’s largest flows of money between continents.’
‘The railways enabled Indians to travel around their country. To bring families together and to inadvertedly unite the country, ripe for independence.
‘The movement of people was incidental , except when it served colonial interests. You might think this train has smelly, grotty toilets but spare a thought for the poor Indians herded onto hard wooden benches. The trains they were on had a total absence of amenities.’
‘You must admit the fares today are very low.’
‘They might be now now but back in the Raj Indians still paid the highest third-class train fares in the world . Indian freight rates, in comparison, were some of the lowest.” he said.
‘They were democratising vehicles providing a meeting place where Indians could mix with the British and Europeans..’
‘‘They do now but during the Raj there were compartments reserved for whites only. Indians found the available affordable space grossly inadequate for their numbers.’
‘The network created jobs for Indians.’
‘Indians weren’t employed initially in the system. The prevailing view was that the railways would have to be staffed almost exclusively by Europeans to “protect investments”. This was especially true of signallers, and those who operated and repaired the steam trains, but the policy was extended to the absurd level that even early this century all the key employees, from directors of the Railway Board to ticket-collectors, were white men – whose salaries and benefits were also paid at European, not Indian levels and largely repatriated back to England.’
‘The British must have encouraged the low paid Indians to build the trains.’
‘You’d think so but it didn’t work like that. Railway workshops were established in the eighteen sixties to maintain the rolling stock, but their Indian mechanics became so adept that in the latter part of the nineteenth century they started designing and building their own locomotives. Their success increasingly alarmed the British, since the Indian locomotives were just as good, and a great deal cheaper, than the British made ones. Come the new century, therefore, the British passed an act of parliament explicitly making it impossible for Indian workshops to design and manufacture locomotives. Most locomotives came from England and other industrially advanced countries, but none were made in India after the act.’
‘So by stifling production of engines at home, Britain retained its grip on the technology as the supplier of all its equipment, which meant once again that the profits were repatriated.’
‘They controlled everything. After independence, 35 years later, the old technical knowledge was so completely lost to India that the Indian Railways had to go cap-in-hand to the British to guide them on setting up a locomotive factory in India again.’
So you see the British policy as one of economic sabotage.’
‘It was from the word go designed to deny India the opportunity to develop it’s own industrial base.. The East India Company smashed India’s advanced textiles industries, literally by demolishing factories and imposing huge tariffs on exports to Britain. In doing so, they turned a manufacturing, shipbuilding nation into a source of raw materials with little scope for value adding industries. India was reduced by the depredations of imperial rule to one of the poorest, most backward, illiterate and diseased societies on Earth by the time of independence in 1947.
‘The British gave India democracy, a free press, and the rule of law. Don’t these fruits of European Enlightenment, these expressions of a higher moral and social order count for anything?’
‘However strongly they denied to Indians- as they had to Americans before 1776, ‘the rights of Englishmen’—the British did instil sufficient dose of the ethos of democracy into their former colonies. So much so it outlived their tutelage. But the actual history of British rule does not suggest this was either policy or practice. A democracy cannot function without a free press and just law. Neither truly existed under the Raj.’
‘Can you deny the British were the first to establish newspapers, the lifeline of every literate individual in India’
‘ These catered to a small English-educated elite first, and large audiences in the vernacular languages later. It was this proliferation that led to their being censored by the Company.’
‘How was this carried out?’I asked.
‘All newspapers were subjected to scrutiny before publication. Under subsequent controls, publishers were required to provide a hefty security deposit, which they would forfeit if the publication carried what were considered inflammatory or abusive articles.’
‘Was the British-owned press treated the same?’
‘Their racism was not subject to the same restrictions, the most infamous being the draconian law passed after the First World War. This suspended basic civil liberties for those suspected of plotting against the Empire. It meant you could be imprisoned without trial for up to two years simply for having what was considered a seditious newspaper. This measure and the protests against it led to the massacre at Amritsar. It provided the first nail in the coffin of the Empire.’
‘How do you judge the justice system under the Raj?’
‘The justice system in India was even more discriminatory. For instance, If you, a British subject, were to have gotten angry with me, your Man Friday, and pushed me off the train to my death, you’d have got six months in jail and a modest fine. But an Indian convicted of the attempted rape of an Englishwoman was sentenced to twenty years. ‘The death of an Indian at British hands was always an accident, and that of a Briton because of an Indian’s actions always a capital crime. The imperial system of law was, pure and simple, an instrument of colonial control.’
‘Thank goodness that all came to an end.’
‘Regrettably the legacy remains. The British legal system has left India with an unenviable judicial backlog. There are still cases pending that were filed during the days of the Raj.’
“The court system, the penal code, the respect for jurisprudence, and the value system of justice—even if they were not applied fairly to Indians in the colonial era—are all worthy legacies,”
‘That’s as may be. But in the process Britain has saddled us with an adversarial legal system, excessively bogged down in procedural formalities, which is far removed from India’s traditional systems of justice.’
‘They acted graciously in defeat. They were benevolent by giving us independence’.’
‘Freedom is never given’, replied the republican. It has always to be wrested from the oppressor.’
Allow me to compliment you on your facility for the English language.’said the anglophile. ‘Doesn’t that confirm that at least in one respect you’ve benefited from their presence?’
‘The British made it absolutely clear that it was only taught to serve their own purpose. Lord Macaulay wrote and I quote: ‘We must do our best to form a class who may be interpreters between us and the millions whom we govern; a class of persons Indians in blood and colour, but English in taste, in opinion, in morals, and in intellect.’ This is the same politician who also said, ‘A single shelf of a good European library was worth the whole native literature of India and Arabia.’
‘It is evident that Macaulay’s understanding of India was awful.’I said. ‘He was undoubtedly a colonial apologist and racist. It’s commendable you have the ability to understand this mindset and reveal it so convincingly.’
‘Indians seized the English language and turned it into an instrument for our own liberation. My whole point is that this was to their credit, not by British design.’
‘You articulate a savage condemnation of that colonising nation. Yet you don’t appear to bear grudges against the British,Swami,’I said, addressing him with the title of respect conferred on the learned, ‘How do explain this lack of rancour?’
‘The opposition to the British was non-violent. This is the key to understanding why there is not more resentment and anger between the two nations. Let me repeat the answer of our first Prime Minister , Jawaharlal Nehru, when Winston Churchill asked him why he didn’t feel more bitterness about all the years of imprisonment he’d suffered at the hands of the British.
‘I was taught by a great man, Mahatma Gandhi, never to fear and never to hate,’ Nehru is said to have replied. we should forgive because hatred is a terrible emotion, but we should never forget. People can forget too soon.’
The Tracks of Their Tears.
Having rolled across the flat fertile plains of Northern India to Delhi, I would next find myself hurtling down the dusty plains to Karachi via the necessary stop for customs and the walk through no mans land to link up with the Pakistani rail system. This was a major transit route in 1947 for millions fleeing the communal violence following partition. On their way out, the British had facilitated this. partitioning the subcontinent into India and Pakistan overnight hastening the mad scramble of displaced people. Trains travelling along this route were jam-packed with people sitting on the roof and hanging from the sides,. Millions fleeing the savagery assumed a train ticket would assure them of reaching safety but they were most vulnerable to attack by the rampaging hordes.Easy targets.Bodies littered the tracks.
What was the response of the British Government to this outpouring of hatred and recrimination.?
Their attitude was one of blithe indifference.Nothing was properly handed over.There was a sense of secret satisfaction that, ‘Well you know,India’s falling apart.We brought unity and they messed it all up.We told them so.
The massacres loom large in the Indian imagination.The image of the moving train loaded with corpses still haunts the nation.Daily life on the subcontinent has continued to be convulsed by such eruptions of bloodshed and savagery, in marked contrast to that of a golden age in its civilization about which I would now explore.
Leaning on his horn, overtaking an obstinate procession of camels and small wooden wheeled carts my taxidriver from the local train station dropped me at Mohenjo-daro. This most extensively excavated site of the 4500 year old Indus Valley Civilization consisted of 400 cities and towns along the Indus River. Mohenjo-daro was its bustling centre. At one time the largest city in the world, it existed when the pyramids were being built and the inhabitants of Britain were still living in the Stone Age.
After checking into a small onsite guesthouse, I made my way over to the site which I would spend the following days poring over. Its onsite museum would be my reference. It preserves a repertory of artifacts and tells the stories of the ruins in large murals. These take the mind back in time showing the vital role of the river in this advanced civilization, enabling extensive trade.
In antiquity the climate was much cooler and much rainier than the present desert suggest. Today’s flow of the Indus 5 kilometers to the west of the site is the Rosetta Stone for the city’s depopulation.
Walking through these deserted streets, I thought of Mortimer Wheeler, one of a handful of noted archeologists to have yielded its secrets. He was familiar with every inch. In studying pre-history, I regarded his patient achievement as very valuable. In both fieldwork and academic archaeology, the range and standard of his work made him a leading figure of international archaeology in the 20th Century. He was a great popularizer of his subject, particularly on television where I came to see him. Like his friend Sir Max Mallowan, he helped illuminate early societies.
Through his digs Sir Mortimer threw light on life in Roman and pre-Roman Britain and the early civilization of the Indus Valley, like others in early Asia traditionally papered over in extent and importance. Director-general of archaeology in India, he worked to particular effect at Mohenjo Daro and Harappa whose citizens were descendants of early groups of Homo sapiens migrating from Africa.
I told him I appreciated his spectacular ability to present scholarly subjects in easily intelligible terms.
I told this veteran of two world wars, whose first experience of trenches were of those he saw dug for military defence, ‘I wish you and yours the best for your remaining years. Growing old, things can only get better. No longer will your life be in ruins.’
Walking through the main streets and the by lanes of this city, soaking up it’s heritage, I visualized its colourful daily life as it would have been nearly five thousand years ago. The most striking feature was how well organized its builders were. The wide streets were laid out according to a symmetric plan on a rectangular grid. Bricks were baked to a standard size throughout the civilization, being used by master masons familiar with plumblines and water levels to build houses of two or more storeys high, their walls exposed by excavation. Fired bricks had been used for the foundations, unfired for the walls. The houses of typical brick and timber construction are similar to those lived in today. Max Mallowan pointed out the continuity in the system of weights and measures that would have enabled this construction. The houses feature bathing pools, living spaces and central courtyards and staircases that would have lead to the roof and drainage shutes. The complex water management system of guttering, sewerage and drainage were far more efficient than most of those I encountered on this journey. Each house had had a well tiled bathroom and its own well. Brick containers were conveniently placed for rubbish disposal. At the top of the city was the spectacular communal bath for public ablutions round which there had been a gallery of fountains.
Sir Mortimer had been ‘touched’ by my “charming words” as I had been by his in conveying the wonder of Mohenjo daro and enticing me there. I could feel the same spell he fell under when unearthing its hidden delights. They were in abundance, he noted in an excavation report: “Stratified potshards and other objects were recovered literally by the ton; four weeks after the beginning, twelve loads of selected pottery were sent back to base and more followed.In recognition of his carrying all these heavy,bulky loads he gained the title ‘Sir Mortuary Wheelbarrow’. He mentioned “toys .. which provide an animated account of life in the ancient metropolis”. They had prompted others to conclude these had been cities of children. One of these toys was an artifact in the museum, a miniature terracotta model of a small wooden wheeled cart, just like the ones I had passed in my taxi on the way here.
The cart could well have been the plaything of the Dancing Girl of Mohenjo-daro, Mortimer Wheelers favourite statuette. I paid my money for a copy of the statuette to the assistant at the museum, a lady dressed in a tunic and trousers, modest by Western standards but pushing the limits set by the local religious hardliners. The bronze statuette of the hoochie coochie girl with her shameless posture and her legs slightly forward as she beat time to the music with her legs and feet exudes a sensuality that is as captivating today as it was thousands of years ago. Sir Mortimer would say of her in a 1973 television program ‘there is her little Baluchi style face with pouting lips and insolent look in her eye. She’s about fifteen years old I should think, not more, but she stands there with bangles all the way up her arm and nothing else on. A girl for the moment, perfectly confident of herself and the world. There’s nothing like her I think in the world.”
The world in which this free spirit lived appears to have been a pleasant , carefree one with no formal religion, no great differences of income, a fairly egalitarian one. Its arcadian citizens seem to have been a truly liberal people who, unlike us, spent little time and resources on war, on arms and weapons and killing others. Instead they crafted their valuable hoard of metals to make jewellery, tools and exquisite masterpieces of sculpture. Archaeologists believe they produced muslin of the finest weave.
To recreate this world and find my very own Dancing Girl became the object of my pursuit.
Up the Khyber.
“We have nothing to fear from Afghanistan. And offensive though it may be to our pride, the less they see of us, the less they will dislike us.”
General Roberts speaking at the end of the second Anglo-Afghan war, in 1881 after pulling out of the country following heavy British casualties.
“My dear boy, as long as you do not invade Afghanistan you will be absolutely fine.”
Attributed to Harold Macmillan, handing over the prime ministership to Alec Douglas-Home in October 1963 .
After the flat and baking fertile plains of Pakistan, through tunnels , along hairpin bends I dropped in on the landlocked land of pomegranates. The monarchy’s border itself was practically deserted,apart from a few soldiers milling about in their fatigues. At customs the official there gave me a form to fill out and stamped my passports with barely a glance.
Others were there to drop out. Yet to be struck by the bulldozer of idustrialisation, the country’s appeal for young travellers was it’s very absence. A culture arrested in time.
Sitting high in the Hindu Kush, the Afghan capital is overlooked by mighty snow-capped peaks. Once I’d offloaded my bags, I pushed off to take in it’s sights and sounds. while the cry of the muezzin summoned the faithful to the mosque, I myself headed to the bazaar. It announced itself with a powerful waft of tea, spices and kebab smoke. I entered the dusty tangle of winding lanes that twisted in and out, intersecting and overlapping to form a jumble of mazes. It was like stepping back into the medieval past. I passed dazzling treasure troves of brassware, spilling out onto the streets with trays and teapots studded in silver grapevines and arabesque design. Stalls were laid out with bountiful supplies of pomegranates and flat breads that looked like snowshoes.. Vendors without overheads draped their shoulders with numerous coats. Men sat on the ground against a wall got their hair cut while watching the crowd go by. Beneath a wall of shrieking birdcages, a man in a skullcap mumbled over prayer beads. There were tribesmen armed to the teeth, pistols in their belts, even swords and daggers. Muskets and bayonets from the three Anglo-Afghan wars were for sale in one stall. The bayonets had serrated edges which meant the victims having to be trodden on for them to be pulled out. On the ‘plus’ side, it widened the wound on the way out!
As I was glancing over these – thinking of the chests the blades had run through, springing a leak like stuck pigs, good times all around – a well groomed man with a neatly trimmed beard came up to the stall and started chatting to me. He was well turned out from head to foot with silver embroidered vest, silk shirt, satin baggy-trousers, green striped chapan coat and astrakhan hat.
‘Salaam,’ he said, bowing and touching his forehead with his hand. ‘Peace be with you. A penny for your thoughts.’
I answered, ‘They must have some stories to tell’, referring to the artefacts on sale.
‘You’re interested in such things?’
‘I am.”I replied.’
‘ Allow me to explain their place in our history. As children, learning to walk we all learn about our jihad against the British, he told me proudly, raising his extended index finger higher and higher into the air as he spoke. ‘ In the last century the British were obsessed with the idea that their rival, Russia, was considering invading us. They fretted that our land would be a staging post for an attack on ‘their’ India. They saw it as an immediate threat to British national security.’
’We know this period of mutual suspicion and paranoia as “The Great Game”, I said.
‘It was not cricket. With their military superiority, the redcoats marched in with an imperial swagger, carrying with them every comfort of home.
‘Just like the Americans on the march’, I said . ‘What we see today in Vietnam.’
‘The British 16th Lancers even brought a pack of foxhounds with them into Afghanistan in 1839. Not that these could save them. Our warriors are like our keen sighted Afghan hounds.
‘They’re more closely related to wolves than most dogs, I believe.”
‘Absolutely. These sighthounds pursue their prey, keeping it in sight, and overpowering it by their great speed and agility. You see, It’s easy to launch an invasion of our countryIt’s much harder to get out in one piece. We have fought off invaders all the way back to Genghis Khan. It’s not for nothing our country is known as ‘the graveyard of empire’. We don’t take to being occupied easily. And when we are, it’s hard to get our land of stones and men to pay the bill. After all you can’t get blood out of a stone.’
‘The defeat of the British would have been the greatest military humiliation ever suffered by the West in the East to date.’
‘The entire army of what was then the most powerful nation in the world was utterly destroyed by poorly-equipped tribesmen. It seems like the U. S. will suffer the same fate in Vietnam. It looks increasingly like they’ve reached their due date.’
‘What legacy did the British leave on the country?’ I asked.
‘To suit themselves they left it undeveloped. They brought about a series of regime changes and left a small Afghan elite attempting to impose western-inspired ideas and modernity on the country. Yes, you can see young men of the elite here spending cash, talking trash, dressing fine, making time. They copy your travellers and grow their hair while girls shorten their hemlines, but these changes are cosmetic, superficial and futile.’
All show and no go.’
‘They may well be forced to go. Resistance to the occupiers has often been expressed through great savagery and fanaticism. This is not the natural way of our people.’
Bordered to the north by the the Soviet Union, sandwiched between the U. S. allies Pakistan and Iran, foreign governments were taking a threatening interest in the country, seeing it as a centre point in the Cold War. The U. S. feared a push south by the U. S. S. R. in search of a warm water port and oil supplies. The U. S. S. R. feared the U. S. was fomenting instability on their southern frontier. Both were jockeying for influence, pumping millions of roubles and dollars into it’s infrastructure through aid and loans.
I witnessed the motorcade of Spiro Agnew, the American Vice President, speed by in a flash. He wasn’t going to present himself as a highly visible target any more than his successors today who pass by with all possible dispatch, as did the Russians who would also get caught by the short hairs.
Rather than procuring the inside-out fleece known in the west as the Afghan coat, much prized by hippies at the time, I got fitted out with and toyed with the idea of buying a leopard skin coat. However I baulked at the final decision when I thought better of its future restrictiveness. I’d never be able pull off the ‘cool’ of Jimmy Hendrix-only the bell bottoms.
Thank goodness I didn’t buy it. One coat with it’s soft and beautifully marked fur is made from up to seven members of this magnificent endangered cat. I didn’t know that at the time.
In what is officially named Chicken Street in Kabul, the freak area, I dropped into a chye shop. It was places like this where travellers swapped road stories and snippets of information, got the latest news about border situations, visas, rip-offs, and good and bad hotels. A message board allowed travellers to leave notes for anyone and everyone they know. Through it I met up with Max and Wolf, a Swiss and German, who were driving a Holden, still a wholly made Australian made car, to Europe. When they told me they had space available, I decided to throw my lot in with these overlanders and share expenses for the trip. Keen on making a beeline to Europe, here I was retracing the Silk Road in style crossing swordlike mountains, high plateaus and deserts, whirlwinds gusting from the car back to the horizon. Looking at these isolated and barren landscapes, its hard to believe why any invading army would want to come charging in. These were the same hills and passes from which local footsoldiers attacked foreign troops. But this is where where the British, to the sound of bagpipes, planted their nation’s flags in their unwinnable wars.
The highways were up to date, built half by the Russians, half by the Americans, having been played off each other by the local government. We encountered pastoral nomads on camels, materialising out of nothing, in the middle of nowhere, moving around the country with their herds as the seasons changed. Sometimes we saw their low black tents from the road. Turbaned traders came out of nowhere tending iceboxes full of Coca-Cola which they sold to thirsty travellers. Overtaking peasants on donkeys we drove past mud houses in small self ruled villages, no women to be seen on the streets. Cut off from the capital, these communities posed no threat to the outside world. We drove past bustling bazaars, minarets, trucks with their cabins heavily decorated, body panels painted with colourful scenes. and decrepit, fried out kombi vans often with peace symbols and psychedelia-polka dots, purple paisley and daisies- daubed on the side. Yeah, Baby! Feeling groovy?
The code of the road insisted that motorists assist any fellow drivers whose vehicles have broken down. In one village we stopped to help some women whose car had overheated and whose radiator was spewing out steam. While Max was cooling it down, a local stood on a balcony shaking a carpet. Max shouted up to him, ‘You’re having trouble with yours too, my friend? Won’t it start?’
Afghanistan was, if not united, at peace and that’s what all the visitors wanted. From the wild but welcoming state of anarchy there we moved on to a more restrictive, orderly society.
The Peacock Monarchy.
Onto the Iran border where they were very heavy on drugs. A special exhibition inside the border compound showed the many ways people have tried -and failed- to smuggle drugs in. Max imagined the life of the drug enforcement officer we saw leading a sniffer dog: ‘I feel sorry for him. Imagine what he has to go through every day, taking drugs. And all those strip and cavity searches. He must come home bushed after his day at the orifice’.
‘These invasive inspections, rough enforcement and language difficulties can lead to intense stress and anger. Officers affected can develop problems managing their emotions and impulses.These procedures can lead to a specific occupational illness.’
‘What is that?’
‘Borderline personality disorder.’
Wolf advised us not to be frivolous with our answers. When one headbanded New Age traveller wearing a jellaba and playing a flute was crossing the border , the customs officers asked if he had any drugs in his tie-died shoulder bag. He said, ‘Well, what do you need?’
It didn’t help him when he asked the probing orificer, ‘Does your wife know you enjoy this?’
What people like him got was another hippy, hippy shakedown.
What he got was being tripped over rather than tripping out. What he got was not so much turning on or tuning in but dropping out.[
As feared a row of backpackers anxiously awaited inspection. They were on the edge of their seats.
A selection of miserable mugshots underlined the message.
Elsewhere shots of the Shah and his wife, the Jackie O of the East, were everywhere ‘Big Brother’-style. Although I had my visa in order, the border guards slugged me with an extra transit .’It’s an old custom’s custom’, Max explained. ‘You’ve just got to grin and bear it.’
Once we were waved through, on the move, parched soil, shrivelling rivers and bare trees told us that Iran which had given the world peaches was in the throes of a major drought. Springs had dried up, seeds withered, crops burned in the fields.Although through doorways we glimpsed women whose faces and figures were hidden by the chador veil, this appeared a much more modern country than the ones I had left behind– if one judged it by the level of sealed roads,city lights, number of cars and other consumer goods and modern buildings. No flying carpets nor snake charmers in sight, the capital at least seemed so modern as against those I had seen so far on this trip, with a smattering of department stores, reasonably orderly roads and cinemas showing Hollywood films. Women in the fast set went unveiled and dressed in high fashion with tight skirts, letting their hair flow and get tussled. At night we strolled along Lalezar Street, filled with cabarets, night clubs, bars, theatres, packed until morning. ‘Wow’, I said as this Cadillac convertible preceded and followed by a motorised police detachment drove along, the well tailored driver sporting a pair of RayBans.
’Maybe the King’s in town,’ I said. thinking of Elvis. As it drew closer I could see it was, but not the one from Graceland. Cruising along the boulevard was the equally capriciously extravagant, homegrown swarthy eyebrowed, full nosed monarch born into the role, also very partial to luxury American-made cars. I had seen him in a newsreel some years earlier riding in one through the streets of Brussels on his official visit.
Back in the hotel we were staying in, it’s reception desk bearing brass busts of the Shah and his infamously fabulous wife, a group of American personnel were busily binging in the lounge. These technical and military officials were there to train the local oil industry technicians force‐feed the West’s most sophisticated military technology quickly to the Shah’s undertrained army. Their table littered with buckets of ice and bottles of Johnnie Walker, they caroused and guzzled grog as if it were going out of fashion. Their tongues loosened, they bellyached about the locals like any western expatriates in any developing country. One complained ‘They’re ‘ unpunctual, inefficient, transparently childish, so fast and loose as to be useless to man and beast,as slippery as eels. They’re unnecessarily suspicious of foreigners. Is this the thanks we get after all we’ve done for them?
‘What have you done for them?’I asked, ‘installed a monarchy to subdue Iran’s Left and secure American access to the country’s oil.’
‘We saved them from becoming yet another domino to fall to the Soviet camp. I would never trust forces that include the Communist Party as partners. I wouldn’t trust their fellow travellers further than I can throw them. They have to be dealt with firmly. The natives were very restless before the Shah restored order, ruling more firmly.’
‘It was your Company’s planners who stirred up considerable unrest in Iran, giving Iranians the supposed clear choice between instability and enabling the Peacock Throne. The move to oust the prime minister only gained substantial popular support this underhand way.’
‘They should thank us for boosting whatever support we have given, especially in the area of health. The peasants are full of disease, you know. Thanks to our aid the Shah’s health corps is eradicating malaria in the countryside, The peasants won’t be grateful of course but the least we can do for them is to help them combat it.’
‘Don’t you think these diseases have got anything to do with the shocking poverty in this oil rich country.’
‘That’s a reach. Most of them, even the poorest looking peasants have some silver or gold jewellery and currency stashed away somewhere. It’s their inertia and superstitions that keeps them sick. They want to stay in the age of the donkey.’
‘Maybe they want to move forward from a monarchy, especially a dictatorial one , to one like the one they voted for in 1952.’
‘Listen, the Pahlavi family come from good blood, from a good tribe. They get things done. Give the Shah credit for the reforms he has carried out. People have learned to read from his literacy corps and received government-subsidised meals and textbooks. He has modernised Iran’s rail infrastructure, He has taken its natural resources back from foreign interests. All in all the Shah is resolved to transform his country into a second America in a generation. He’s dragging his country into the 20th Century.’
‘With some kicking and screaming so it appears. These improvements in people’s lives are to be welcomed. However once you embark on a program of reforms, you’ve got to provide them for everyone who needs to benefit. Foremost among these is freedom of political expression and association. It would be a big mistake for him to hold back from further reforms until it’s too late. Sometimes it is more dangerous to stop doing a dangerous thing than it is to continue doing it.’
‘Life has improved substantially for the middle class during his rule. The White Revolution has led to the growth of an affluent, educated city society’
‘Perhaps life isn’t great for everyone. The economic changes he’s achieved have led to rapid migration from rural areas to cities.He has increased the income gap between rich and poor. On top of this there’s a lot of bitterness regarding the nation’s autonomy. The knowledge by many that Anglo American operations took away their “right to self-determination”. can lead to long-term animosity toward them, particularly to your country. This anti-Western resentment could incubate in fundamentalist fringes over the coming years. Too close an identification with Western culture could stir in them a zealous Islamic awakening. Although the two countries are very different in most ways – Iran has a much greater level of industry and a sizeable working class – we know how this tension between the old and new plays out in Saudi Arabia.’
‘Nothing that a good stiff drink wouldn’t relieve’, said one of the Americans. ‘These mad mullahs need to lighten up. Not so long back theological students led by clerics agitated against a scheduled opening of liquor stores. The Shah had to send in his paratroopers when the locals started going bananas.’
In fact a good number of the Iranian population would have been displeased at the thought of these visitors to their country swilling away into the early hours of the morning. There were those annoyed by the presence of many Americans in their country, those many Iranians saw as having taken the place of the British. If this imbibing had led to any problems they would have wanted to penalise them. Yet any misdemeanours these expats might become involved in would have been overlooked. They were indemnified against prosecution
Near the grand bazaar in Tehran is a colourful mural depicting symbols of Iranian nationalism including a dignified soldier, a machine-gun, and crossed Iranian flags.
Noticing my interest in the gun a young man who introduced himself as Khalil, a post-graduate student of English at Tehran University pointed out to me, ‘That’s a Maxim. Quite fitting wouldn’t you say. This weapon most associated with the British imperial conquest, is thanks to Colt, it’s American makers, now a favourite weapon of our military. Geopolitically it’s to empower Iran as a military power charged with preserving the balance in the Persian Gulf region. Domestically it’s to empower the security apparatus to ruthlessly dealt with all forms of political opposition. It’s favoured maxim when it comes to dealing with students and workers is ‘Shoot first, ask questions aftér.’
‘No warning shots?’
‘In some countries the police shoot in the air — in Iran they shoot straight ahead, that’s a warning for the next guy.”
‘You don’t want to end up like all the political prisoners in the hands of the SAVAK secret police. They’re infamous for their torture,’said Khalil.
‘I’ve heard their screams can be heard throughout the night.’
‘SAVAK are truly in the Space Age.In space, no one can hear you scream. In Iran you are gagged when you scream.’
‘I’m happy to hear you maintain a good sense of humour.’
‘It’s not easy.In Iran laughing at those in charge is a serious issue. Thumbing our noses at power is a dangerous phenomenon.It has the potential to undermine authority and the ‘good order of society’.’
‘Do you have many comedians performing here?’
‘Many people are surprised to hear that we have comedians in Iran, but they are here. They are dead, but they are are here.’
‘All this cruelty to enforce the Shah’s vision of democracy,’I suggested.
‘Democracy!What kind of democracy is this? The Shah has shredded the vestiges of the only one we had. What else can you expect. This country is owned and ruled by an oligarchy. People refer to it’s members as ‘one thousand families’.
‘Just who are the main ones?’ I asked.
‘The big landowners. One of the greatest, not surprisingly is the Shah himself. The other main one is the clerical establishment, which acquired land through religious endowments. The Shah, meanwhile, enjoys the support of Iran’s upper and middle classes, and he has the support of clerics who see him as an alternative to the political Left. They made a united front against the democratically elected government which both leaderships saw as their common threat.’
‘How much power does the monarchy allow the religious establishment?’
‘There are tensions between the monarchy and the conservative Shia establishment. The power and influence of Shia scholars has diminished under Pahlavi dynastic rule. Some clerics, including the Ayatollah Ruhollah Khomeini, were offended a decade ago when the Shah gave himself the authority to initiate legislation.’
‘Presumably the Ayatollah would prefer to do so himself.’
‘Undoubtedly he would, given half a chance. The Ayatollah can be relied upon to challenge any of the Shah’s edicts. He constantly draws attention to how the Shah’s father barred clerics from acting as judges in state courts. He wants our religion to reorder every aspect of Iranian life.He wants to impose a more austere style of lifestyle on the nation. Hence the monarchy is allied with secularists, especially when they are not associated with the Left and are in conflict with Muslims opposed to the use of tobacco, alcohol, movies, gambling and foreign dress.’
‘Are people in this day and age really willing to give up these indulgences because of religious beliefs?’
The spreading influence of Ayatollah Khomeini is a result not so much of his religious appeal to the masses — although that appeal is considerable — as of their symbolic attachment to his rejection of the Shah’s rule. To the people he is the only leader who proclaims that he will absolutely not compromise with the Shah. They want respect for their history and their identity. He wants to put Islam squarely in the middle of the table in the Middle East.Sharia law would govern Iran and an ‘infallible’ cleric should rule as it’s head. A cleric who received his authority directly from God. He offers the people, under the guise of Islamic principles, a rallying point for their discontent.’
‘How widespread is this discontent?’
‘Discontent is always smoldering under the seemingly tranquil political surface. But why not instead come with me into the Bazaar and I’ll show you some of it’s treasures? And some of the very discontented denizens you would never expect to be so.’
A city within the city, the Bazaar was still the focal point of the city. Traditionally the “Wall Street” of Tehran, and hence Iran, it’s where prices of staple commodities are fixed. It acts as an interface between the town and the country.
Everything happens here, not only trading, but also social relations, marriage and politics. Before we proceed,’said Khalil, ‘let me give you a word of word of warning: Keep closely to the right, well away from the centre of the passageway.Soon enough I realised why. This was to avoid the heavily-laden porters who made their way through the crowd in less time than it takes to tell.
As we strolled through the miles of corridors and galleries, I could smell the spices and the sheepskins, and hear the cries of sellers of goods and their customers, the rhythmic sound of artisan’s hammers of and the rich padded sound of unrolling carpets, unpeeled from the stack like pages of a manuscript.
We passed an entrance leading off to the Grand Mosque. ‘Unlike markets elsewhere,’said Khalil, ‘economy and religion are the two principal pillars of the Islamic bazaars.’
Khalil stopped outside a small café / deli he informed me was run by his father. Glass cabinets lined with colourful scones, and the all-time favourite plum cakes beckoned the passerby to step in for a bite. The eatery had a high ceiling, tiled floors, and mirrored walls giving those seated the impression of extra space’.
After being introduced , the father gestured to me to sit down on the bentwood or bent-cane chairs at one of the Italian marble-topped tables.
‘You wonder why the bazaari class works hard to help advance the Atatollah’s cause. You can now hear straight from the horse’s mouth . My dad is as you can plainly observe a bazaari, a trader, just a medium sized one, but his business keeps him aware of current trends. I will translate for you if you would care to ask him any questions about them.’
‘Sir,’I put it to the father,’ in Australia , business people are generally happy with the monarchy.One from another country at that. Here many of your fellow traders and merchants are not so thrilled with yours, I’m led to believe. Why is this so?’
‘The government of Mohammed Reza Pahlavi is anathema to the bazaaris. As a business, mine has evolved into a dealership in tea and coffee, wine, oils, provisions and cold storage foods. The individual merchants and traders, and the shops we run, are just the tip of an economic iceberg. Behind us lies a vast network of economic and commercial interests. Farmers, carpet makers, jewellers, clothiers, metal smiths, shoemakers, arms and antique sellers and so on. This is where the money is, and in Iran, as everywhere else, money means power.’
‘I notice that not all your clientele appear to be rolling in it.’
‘My establishment is a favourite welcoming place for all classes of people. That is in accordance with the wishes of Allah. It’s known for good, honest, reasonably priced food and beverages. My clients include all different walks of life from Iranian society, ranging from businessmen, to university students, to workers, to artists. Most are invariably individuals of modest means for whom I provide a place to drop-in for an inexpensive hot drink, wholesome snack or a meal – or even to congregate and socialize.It serves a social function as well. It is homely, you can sit here for hours. The ambience and prices have remained the same over years, ‘he said, ‘but this is all changing for the worse. Price increases make it difficult for me to retain many of my long term clients, loyal though they are. Small businesses all seem set to lose out as the country is being rushed headlong into industrialization.’
‘What are your particular concerns?’
‘We fear that we will be left behind and our status in society reduced. Meanwhile merchants and politicians close to the imperial palace and the Shah’s relatives receive exclusive concessions or commissions for vast deals. Millions of dollars are being made by very few people. The Shah does nothing.’
‘And the Atatollah?’
‘He doesn’t want to interfere with us. He will leave us alone. As long we back him he just wants us to carry on with our business. He’s opposed to us being slugged with large taxes by the government.’
‘In this respect at least he sounds rather like Ronald Reagan, the Governor of California ,’I commented.
‘The Shah sounds more like Bozo, Reagan’s chimp. He claims to put the nation’s interests first but he’s allowing too much investment by foreigners. Now I’ll leave you two to enjoy your refreshment while I work to pay the royal tax collectors, adding to the Shah’s overflowing coffers.’
Whereupon Khalil and I set to tucking into the spread his father laid before us. Tea was served in teapots, accompanied with sugar in a pot and milk in a small jug.
‘So how does the Shah maintain the popular backing he depends on to counter this rival establishment?’I asked Khalil.
‘He has sought to increase his power, balancing this with reforms that would win more favour from common Iranians. Many have benefitted from his program of industrial profit-sharing and forced redistribution of land, some of which belonged to the Moslem clergy and absentee landlords, to landless peasants.’
‘That all sounds very progressive and admirable. Will these measures not enable him to hang onto power?’
‘It’s a case of too little, too late. There are signs his White Revolution has largely failed among the country’s predominantly rural population. More and more food is being imported rather than exported. Although it appears progressive in its thrust, the Revolution has fallen short of responding to the needs of the peasants. There has been little follow‐up in the way of financial backing for those who received land, and water for irrigation has been scarce.’
‘I can believe that having seen the parched earth of the farms I rode past. What are things like for other sectors economically?’’
‘Iran lacks the infrastructure to facilitate the demands of the White Revolution. It lacks the roads, the power facilities and the ports to carry out ambitious industrialization projects, so bottlenecks and severe shortages are becoming apparent. As you can see, there’s terrible traffic congestion and pollution.’
I’ve seen it bring citizens to their knees, left gasping for fresh air.’I said. ‘The taxi driver who brought me here says the blanket of smog can be so thick and difficult to see through, he goes through red lights unaware.’
‘On the positive side’ I told him’ nobody can see your licence plate.’
Fortunately right now if you look to our north you can see the massive Alborz mountain range. This stops the flow of the humid Caspian wind. It creates a trap for polluted air just as massive unplanned industrialisation schemes can createan economic trap.It’s a case of too much, too soon. With the booming economy has come a dizzying inflation rate of inflation. Rents have risen many times over in recent years, which take as much as half of a middle-class family’s earnings’.
‘What about the Shah’s much publicized granting suffrage for women and other legal reforms affecting them?’
‘The vote for women is an empty exercise since there have been no free elections. Women have gained the right to become judges and ministers regardless of their gender under his reign. That’s all very fine but few achieve such positions.’
‘They don’t even in Australia,’I said.
‘He has officially stopped child marriage and polygamy, but everyone knows these still go on in the remote areas . Overall these measures have only succeeded in adding fuel to the revolt of the conservative clergy, which views them as an effort to destroy the religious establishment and a contravention of the spirit of Islam.’
‘So you don’t believe the Shah is genuinely interested in sharing power in any meaningful way?’
‘Every decision he makes reflects his determination to consolidate all power and authority in his hands.It’s all for the sake of the dynasty. He ignores his law-abiding opposition and his repressive apparatus tortures those who oppose him, dominating the lives of anyone who thinks differently. This includes groups from among students, intellectuals, industrial workers and religious leaders.’
‘And the usual suspects?’
‘The Communists? Members of their Party were hounded, arrested, tortured and killed. Virtually every independent institution has been subverted including public universities such as mine. It has been heavily infiltrated by the secret police. The curriculums are carefully scrutinized and doctored. People dare not even think about criticizing the system publicly, because of the Savak. I could tell you stories about what they do to prisoners in Evin prison that would make your hair stand on end.’
. As we exited the Bazaar by one of it’s gates a cleric in a turban and a voluminous robe handed Khalil a leaflet. My companion translated for me what the cleric told him. ‘The Shah is a Satan. His decadent lifestyle is funded through oil–our oil-mainly through concessions to Great Britain. Is this how the British repay us having relied heavily upon our oil during both World Wars.’ ‘You’re not British are you?’he said, looking at me.
‘No’ I said, I’m innocent. I’m Australian.’
‘Like the man D’Arcy who found our oil.’
‘Your fool’s oil.’
‘How do you mean?’
‘It’s like fool’s gold. Something that you think will be valuable but turns out otherwise.’
‘Exactly. Where is the value for us? We are tired of working to see our wealth literally extracted from beneath our feet. And how has it set us free? The Shah claims to defend personal freedoms yet he frustrates traditionalists with his ban on religious garments. The Shah is not careful about the Islamic beliefs of half of the society.
This son of a Nazi sympathizer, a mere commoner when it comes down to it, has taken upon himself the title ‘King of Kings’. This is the most hated of titles in the sight of God, according to Shia. The Shah insults and enrages us by drinking wine when on television.
’Can one lay all the blame for this at the feet of one royal?’
‘This diabolic behaviour runs in the family. Look at his sister, Princess Ashraf. She spends her time between Mecca and Monte Carlo casinos. We hear many rumors about her strong sexual appetite and licentious lifestyle.’
‘What do you expect to come out of this?’
‘One day people will rise up against the rule of such a sacrilegious family. The strutting peacock will be no more than-how do you say- a lame duck. By hanging on so tightly to his autocracy he’s only delaying the inevitable. It’s only natural. We want an Iran that is “authentic”. If our will does not prevail, we must submit to an alternative.’
‘If the mountain will not come to Muhammad, then Muhammad must go to the mountain,’ I stated bringing home some Francis Bacon.
End of the Trail.
Finally to Turkey where just over the border we could glimpse Mount Ararat in the distance, the supposed final resting place of Noah’s ark. On to Istanbul, considered the beginning or the end of the hippy trail, depending on which direction you were coming from. Our resting place was a smart hotel offering us a chance to spruce up after our odyssey and a room with a view over the medieval city walls of the Sea of Marmora. From our room we had an outstanding panorama of this fabled city, its hilly silhouettes reflected in the water. The skyline took in hundreds of domed mosques flanked by tapering minarets; its shores were studded with marble palaces, medieval fortresses, mansions, cafes and tea gardens. Along the promenade beneath our hotel loped the dancing bears of the gypsies.
It was a special time to traverse the trail. For the blink of an eyelid the world it covered was in lull. No-one worried overly about their personal safety then, or was afraid to visit someone’s house for dinner or a wedding. All those countries linked up and had open borders. Today such travel is no longer possible. A decade later the shutters would come down. The area would go through extraordinary and roiling change. Difficulty in getting visas, closed borders and sporadic civil unrest make portions of the journey next to impossible. What I see of it in daily reports doesn’t bear any marked resemblance to what I saw of it. Nary a hint of hostility. Life there today is so dramatic and tumultuous that it makes this age look as eventful as a mill pond. Now a western passport, once respected, is a liability in many parts.
Iran closed its borders after the 1979 revolution. Popular resentment boiled over against a monarchy which played host to an increasing number of foreign nationals whose alcohol lifestyles were considered an affront to many strict Shiite Muslims, and which would ignore increasing poverty from such occurrences as drought, while popping the champagne corks for the nobility and foreign visitors to Persepolis in 1972.
Afghanistan became a lawless battleground for the superpowers, one that is still fought over years after the Soviet withdrawal. Both thought they could walk in, set up a friendly government and be out within a year. Both got bogged down in a long and costly war of attrition that in the end both chose to fall back from. Invading countries with a known determined resistance is like entering a lobster pot—it’s easy to get in but the devil’s own job to get out of.
One basic reaction to what happened to the world in the last decades, is to look back, not to look forward. People are scared of looking forward, it’s much easier to look back to the old truths of their religion, to reinforce certainties rather than explore ideas of living, to retreat into insular communities so as to preserve their identity.
I would continue with Max and Wolf to Zurich, their destination, through Yugoslavia, completing my journey through one more of a series of shadowed countries before they fell apart from war and self destruction. This would cause me a good deal of anguish over subsequent years as I considered the fate of so many people I had cast my eyes on or come into contact with. These tragedies would round off what was indeed a most violent century.